Stratification is useful for analyses using matched subjects, for dealing with patient subsets, such as different clinics, and for dealing with violations of the proportional hazard assumption. ", "r.c. Published by Oxford University Press on behalf of ERA-EDTA. Comparison of restricted means provides assessment of treatment effect over a time interval. {\displaystyle [0,\infty ]} I encountered some issues when calculating restricted mean survival time (RMST) in R and I made some attempts. It is also possible that the patient was enrolled early in the study, but was lost to follow up or withdrew from the study. If the event of interest has already happened before the subject is included in the study but it is not known when it occurred, the data is said to be left-censored. In reliability problems, the expected lifetime is called the mean time to failure, and the expected future lifetime is called the mean residual lifetime. For small N, they may differ somewhat. − 0 Wakasugi M, Nagai M, Yokota S, Omori K, Fujikawa H, Aoike I, Omori T, Kazama JJ, Narita I. Intern Med. in the equation below. Using data from 67 258 adult patients in the French Renal Epidemiology and Information Network (REIN) registry, we estimated the RMST of a hypothetical patient cohort (and its subgroups) for the first 15 years after starting RRT (cRMST) and used the general population mortality tables to estimate the expected RMST (pRMST). On the Restricted Mean Survival Time Curve Survival Analysis Author: Lihui Zhao, Brian Claggett, Lu Tian, Hajime Uno, Marc A. Pfeffer, Scott D. Solomon, Lorenzo Trippa, and L. … If the survival of different individuals is independent, the number of survivors at age t has a binomial distribution with parameters n and S(t), and the variance of the proportion of survivors is S(t) × (1-S(t))/n. For uncensored data, with ( Finally, the output gives p-values for three alternative tests for overall significance of the model: These three tests are asymptotically equivalent. Methods for regression analysis of mean survival time and the related quantity, the restricted mean survival time, are reviewed and compared to a method based on pseudo-observations. Censoring / Censored observation: If a subject does not have an event during the observation time, they are described as censored. T The last observation (11), at 161 weeks, is censored. These events at five weeks, eight weeks and so on are indicated by the vertical drops in the KM plot at those time points. i) I fitted a cox regression model to get estimated function of h(t), and I deploy individual covariables to calculate individual h(t); n.risk is the number of subjects at risk immediately before the time point, t. Being "at risk" means that the subject has not had an event before time t, and is not censored before or at time t. n.event is the number of subjects who have events at time t. survival is the proportion surviving, as determined using the Kaplan–Meier product-limit estimate. The Cox PH analysis gives the results in the box. By definition the likelihood function is the conditional probability of the data given the parameters of the model. Am J Cardiovasc Dis. In the node on the far left, the values 1/33 indicate that one of the 33 subjects in the node had an event, and that the relative event rate is 0.122. The restricted mean survival time (RMST), sometimes called the restricted mean event time, is an alternative measure that is more often reliably estimable than the mean and median of the event time in certain situations. The hazard rate is also called the failure rate. The Cox model extends the log-rank test by allowing the inclusion of additional covariates. That is, the survival function is the probability that the time of death is later than some specified time t. {\displaystyle \mu } The hazard ratio HR = exp(coef) = 1.58, with a 95% confidence interval of 0.934 to 2.68. Three kinds of between-group contrast metrics (i.e., the difference in RMST, the ratio of RMST and the ratio of the restricted mean time lost (RMTL)) are computed. In a so-called delayed entry study, subjects are not observed at all until they have reached a certain age. This is the method underlying the survival random forest models. , that is, at birth, this reduces to the expected lifetime. If only the lower limit l for the true event time T is known such that T > l, this is called right censoring. For large enough N, they will give similar results. For each trial, the ratio of restricted mean survival time (RMST) between the arms was based on reconstructed individual patient data for overall survival. r By contrast, the p-value for sex is now p=0.088. The estimated hazard ratio of 1.94 indicates that males have higher risk of death (lower survival rates) than females, in these data. Additional tests and graphs for examining a Cox model are described in the textbooks cited. The RMST is the mean survival time of all subjects in the study population followed up to t, and is simply the area under the survival curve up to t. H or The use of restricted mean survival time to estimate the treatment effect in randomized clinical trials when the proportional hazards assumption is in doubt - Royston - 2011 - Statistics in Medicine - Wiley Online Library {\displaystyle \Lambda } RMST is defined as the area under the survival curve up to a point t*. t i Nephron Clin Pract. T As the probability of an individual surviving until age t or later is S(t), by definition, the expected number of survivors at age t out of an initial population of n newborns is n × S(t), assuming the same survival function for all individuals. i This topic is called reliability theory or reliability analysis in engineering, duration analysis or duration modelling in economics, and event history analysis in sociology. is known not to have occurred before an observation time and to have occurred before the next observation time. S Restricted Mean Survival Time as a Measure to Interpret Clinical Trial Results JAMA Cardiol. t Elshahat S, Cockwell P, Maxwell AP, Griffin M, O'Brien T, O'Neill C. PLoS One. Keywords: However, computing the likelihood function (needed for fitting parameters or making other kinds of inferences) is complicated by the censoring. Usage t where the second expression is obtained using integration by parts. The first aim of this article was to provide an overview of the restricted mean survival time. This implies that This example uses the melanoma data set from Dalgaard Chapter 14. doi: 10.1016/S1769-7255(13)70036-1. {\displaystyle T_{i}} In mechanical reliability problems, one can bring cost (or, more generally, utility) into consideration, and thus solve problems concerning repair or replacement. p=0.013. The likelihood function for a survival model, in the presence of censored data, is formulated as follows. {\displaystyle H} Rpart and the stagec example are described in the PDF document "An Introduction to Recursive Partitioning Using the RPART Routines". The investigator I am working for, however, does not feel that Kaplan Meier curves or hazard rates are intuitive from a clinician point of view. For a life aged x, the force of mortality t years later is the force of mortality for a (x + t)–year old. COVID-19 is an emerging, rapidly evolving situation. This example use the melanoma data set where the predictor variables include a continuous covariate, the thickness of the tumor (variable name = "thick"). The Kaplan–Meier estimator can be used to estimate the survival function. He said that clinicians expect to see a "Restricted Mean Survival Time Curve." The number of years lost in all subgroups followed a bell curve that was highest for patients aged 70 years. UK Renal Registry 15th annual report: Chapter 5 survival and causes of death of UK adult patients on renal replacement therapy in 2011: national and centre-specific analyses. Restricted mean survival time (RMST) is an underutilized estimand in time-to-event analyses. ) The hazard function can alternatively be represented in terms of the cumulative hazard function, conventionally denoted Restricted mean survival time is a measure of average survival time up to a specified time point. For quantitative predictor variables, an alternative method is Cox proportional hazards regression analysis. There are five tick marks in the KM plot, corresponding to these censored observations. 2020 Apr 1;59(7):927-932. doi: 10.2169/internalmedicine.3943-19. Herein, we highlight its strengths by comparing time to (1) all-cause mortality and (2) initiation of antiretroviral therapy (ART) for HIV-infected persons who inject drugs (PWID) and persons who do … The question of interest is whether recurrence occurs later in maintained patients than in non-maintained patients. Suppose that an item has survived for a time t and we desire the probability that it will not survive for an additional time dt: Force of mortality is a synonym of hazard function which is used particularly in demography and actuarial science, where it is denoted by ( where t is some time, T is a random variable denoting the time of death, and "Pr" stands for probability. To answer such questions, it is necessary to define "lifetime". 3 - 5 It is equivalent to the area under the Kaplan-Meier curve from the beginning of the study through that point. t {\displaystyle \mu (x)=-{d \over dx}\ln(S(x))={\frac {f(x)}{S(x)}}}. Cox PH models work also with categorical predictor variables, which are encoded as {0,1} indicator or dummy variables. Conclusion: The log-rank test determines if the observed number of events in each group is significantly different from the expected number. x The log of the thickness of the tumor looks to be more normally distributed, so the Cox models will use log thickness. t At the far right end of the KM plot there is a tick mark at 161 weeks. Everyone is familiar with the use of median survival, or more generally with median time to event (where the event could be progression or treatment failure), to … In particular, the di erence in the area under the Kaplan-Meier survival curve up to time ˝is not necessarily a consistent es- ( It is similar to linear regression and logistic regression. Can multiple causes of death or failure be taken into account? Left-truncated data are common in actuarial work for life insurance and pensions. Results: Twenty-five RCTs totaling 12 870 patients were included in this study. ) | The survival function is usually assumed to approach zero as age increases without bound (i.e., S(t) → 0 as t → ∞), although the limit could be greater than zero if eternal life is possible. Furthermore, without PH, the estimated HR is not a simple average of HRs over time, and is even more difficult to interpret. An alternative to building a single survival tree is to build many survival trees, where each tree is constructed using a sample of the data, and average the trees to predict survival. μ , we have. The impact of chronic kidney disease on developed countries from a health economics perspective: A systematic scoping review. Tree-structured survival models may give more accurate predictions than Cox models. The hazard function must be non-negative, λ(t) ≥ 0, and its integral over d Time: The time from the beginning of an observation period (such as surgery or beginning treatment) to (i) an event, or (ii) end of the study, or (iii) loss of contact or withdrawal from the study. Unlike median survival time, it is estimable even under heavy censoring. We developed a conditional restricted mean survival time (CRMST) estimator for a time interval of interest using counting process. Because the confidence interval for HR includes 1, these results indicate that sex makes a smaller contribution to the difference in the HR after controlling for the thickness of the tumor, and only trend toward significance. When the log-rank statistic is large, it is evidence for a difference in the survival times between the groups. 0 Epub 2017 May 15. James Frank Bishop AO is an Australian doctor and the Chief Medical Officer of Australia between 2009 and 2011.. Bishop graduated from University of Melbourne with a Bachelor of Medicine, Bachelor of Surgery in 1972. t ∞ time gives the time points at which events occur. Thus the expected proportion of survivors is S(t). Note that truncation is different from left censoring, since for a left censored datum, we know the subject exists, but for a truncated datum, we may be completely unaware of the subject. Version: In some cases alternative partitions give more accurate classification or quantitative estimates. The summary for the Cox model gives the hazard ratio for the second group relative to the first group, that is, male versus female. ) Nephrol Ther. {\displaystyle T_{i}} t Given this property, the lifetime distribution function and event density (F and f below) are well-defined. ) The force of mortality of the survival function is defined as which is the "accumulation" of the hazard over time. eCollection 2020. Any function h is a hazard function if and only if it satisfies the following properties: In fact, the hazard rate is usually more informative about the underlying mechanism of failure than the other representatives of a lifetime distribution. For this example use a log transform. For example, in an epidemiological example, we may monitor a patient for an infectious disorder starting from the time when he or she is tested positive for the infection. Time-varying covariates. The Nelson–Aalen estimator can be used to provide a non-parametric estimate of the cumulative hazard rate function. exp(coef) = 1.94 = exp(0.662) - The log of the hazard ratio (coef= 0.662) is transformed to the hazard ratio using exp(coef). The proportional hazard assumption may be tested using the R function cox.zph(). The probability of death at or before age A vertical drop indicates an event. A difference in restricted mean survival time represents a life benefit or loss over the studied period. The Cox PH regression model is a linear model. Stratification. ( T [2]. The restricted mean survival time is a robust and clinically interpretable summary measure of the survival time distribution. h ) Restricted mean survival time (RMST) can provide additional insight to the survival distribution and is not subject to underestimation by definition. ( give examples of survival analyses using R (or using S, and which run in R). se(coef) = 0.265 is the standard error of the log hazard ratio. t Truncation is also common. {\displaystyle T_{i,l}} Here are some example data, taken from the paper. ] The Likelihood ratio test has better behavior for small sample sizes, so it is generally preferred. The lifetime distribution function, conventionally denoted F, is defined as the complement of the survival function. Censoring is a form of missing data problem in which time to event is not observed for reasons such as termination of study before all recruited subjects have shown the event of interest or the subject has left the study prior to experiencing an event. An important application where interval-censored data arises is current status data, where an event x This example of a survival tree analysis uses the R package "rpart". Terry M. Therneau, Elizabeth J. Atkinson, Mayo Foundation. The null hypothesis for a log-rank test is that the groups have the same survival. The theory outlined below assumes well-defined events at specific times; other cases may be better treated by models which explicitly account for ambiguous events. , given survival until age The expected number of subjects surviving at each time point in each is adjusted for the number of subjects at risk in the groups at each event time. For example, people may not be observed until they have reached the age to enter school. is not the hazard function of any survival distribution, because its integral converges to 1. i Any deceased subjects in the pre-school age group would be unknown. Restricted mean survival time is a viable alternative to HR, particularly when the proportional hazards assumption is not satisfied. , we have, For an interval censored datum, such that the age at death is known to be less than {\displaystyle \Lambda (t)} | [4], Left-censored data can occur when a person's survival time becomes incomplete on the left side of the follow-up period for the person. T doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0230512. One set of alternative methods are tree-structured survival models, including survival random forests. exp Results were expressed in three different ways: the cRMST, which calculates the years of life gained under the hypothesis of 100% death without RRT treatment, the difference between the pRMST and the cRMST (the years lost), and a ratio expressing the percentage reduction of the expected RMST: (pRMST - cRMST)/pRMST. What is the recommended way of calculating confidence intervals for the restricted mean in survival analysis? The UCLA website http://www.ats.ucla.edu/stat/ has numerous examples of statistical analyses using SAS, R, SPSS and STATA, including survival analyses. {\displaystyle \exp(-t)} For the melanoma data, p=0.222, indicating that the hazards are, at least approximately, proportional. We generally encounter right-censored data. Description Usage Arguments Details Value Note Author(s) References Examples. All rights reserved. Background: The restricted mean survival time (RMST) estimates life expectancy up to a given time horizon and can thus express the impact of a disease. 2013 Sep;9 Suppl 1:S3-6. Although we may know the right-hand side of the duration of interest, we may never know the exact time of exposure to the infectious agent.[5]. The same is true for the diagnosis of AIDS, which is based on clinical symptoms and needs to be confirmed by a medical examination. This subject was in the study for only 13 weeks, and the aml cancer did not recur during those 13 weeks. The aim of this article is to summarize the role of restricted mean survival time (RMST) analysis in oncology. The aim of this study was to estimate the 15-year RMST of a hypothetical cohort of incident patients starting renal replacement therapy (RRT), according to their age, gender ( In the present article the restricted mean net survival time was used to derive a specific test statistic to compare net survivals in proportional and non-proportional hazards settings. How do particular circumstances or characteristics increase or decrease the probability of survival? This data is from the Mayo Clinic Primary Biliary Cirrhosis (PBC) trial of the liver conducted between 1974 and 1984. = 2020 Mar 1;35(3):488-495. doi: 10.1093/ndt/gfz208. must be infinite, but is not otherwise constrained; it may be increasing or decreasing, non-monotonic, or discontinuous. The p-value corresponding to z=2.5 for sex is p=0.013, indicating that there is a significant difference in survival as a function of sex. i Other clinical variables, such as serum protein levels or dose of concomitant medications may change over the course of a study. For example, Lead times for metallic components in the aerospace industry, This page was last edited on 2 January 2021, at 16:34. Thus, it is equal to the age at death, we have, For left-censored data, such that the age at death is known to be less than The restricted mean survival time (RMST) estimates life expectancy up to a given time horizon and can thus express the impact of a disease. 0 It is possible that this patient was enrolled near the end of the study, so that they could be observed for only 13 weeks. The randomForestSRC package includes an example survival random forest analysis using the data set pbc. {\displaystyle T-t_{0}} The log-rank test is a special case of a Cox PH analysis, and can be performed using Cox PH software. Pediatr Nephrol. UK Renal Registry 16th annual report: chapter 8 survival and cause of death of UK adult patients on renal replacement therapy in 2012: national and centre-specific analyses. std.err is the standard error of the estimated survival. t Overall survival was used as … i has examples of survival analyses using SAS, R, and other packages. T Epub 2014 Feb 14. Nephrol Dial Transplant. The textbook by Kleinbaum t Restricted mean survival time (RMST) is a useful summary measurement of the time-to-event data, and it has attracted great attention for its straight We use cookies to enhance your experience on our website.By continuing to use our website, you are agreeing to our use of cookies. The columns in the life table have the following interpretation: The log-rank test compares the survival times of two or more groups. 2020 Mar 24;15(3):e0230512. The survival function is also called the survivor function or survivorship function in problems of biological survival, and the reliability function in mechanical survival problems. S For the example data, the log-rank test for difference in survival gives a p-value of p=0.0653, indicating that the treatment groups do not differ significantly in survival, assuming an alpha level of 0.05. Survival in children requiring chronic renal replacement therapy. Right censoring will occur, for example, for those subjects whose birth date is known but who are still alive when they are lost to follow-up or when the study ends. 1,2 In this article, we discuss the advantages of an alternative analytical procedure based on the restricted mean survival time (RMST) 1,2 via 3 examples. 0 The graph shows KM plots for the aml data broken out by treatment group, which is indicated by the variable "x" in the data. λ This reflects the notion that survival to a later age is possible only if all younger ages are attained. The mean survival time will in general depend on what value is chosen for the maximum survival time. − The age at which a specified proportion of survivors remain can be found by solving the equation S(t) = q for t, where q is the quantile in question. The term hazard rate is another synonym. The p-value for log(thick) is 6.9e-07, with a hazard ratio HR = exp(coef) = 2.18, indicating a strong relationship between the thickness of the tumor and increased risk of death. Censoring indicates that the patient did not have an event (no recurrence of aml cancer). SSRMST: Sample Size Calculation using Restricted Mean Survival Time Calculates the power and sample size based on the difference in Restricted Mean Survival Time. The graph shows the KM plot for the aml data and can be interpreted as follows: A life table summarizes survival data in terms of the number of events and the proportion surviving at each event time point. Chesnaye NC, van Stralen KJ, Bonthuis M, Harambat J, Groothoff JW, Jager KJ. In actuarial science, the hazard rate is the rate of death for lives aged x. The Association between Earlobe Creases and Cardiovascular Events in Japanese Hemodialysis Patients: A Prospective Cohort Study. lower 95% CI and upper 95% CI are the lower and upper 95% confidence bounds for the proportion surviving. = , we see that it increases without bound as t tends to infinity (assuming that S(t) tends to zero). | The vertical tick mark indicates that a patient was censored at this time. A censored subject may or may not have an event after the end of observation time. The life table summarizes the events and the proportion surviving at each event time point. The R. coef = 0.662 is the estimated logarithm of the hazard ratio for males versus females. September 3, 1997. (2014). On the restricted mean event time in survival analysis Lu Tian, Lihui Zhao and LJ Wei February 26, 2013 Abstract For designing, monitoring and analyzing a longitudinal study with an event time as the outcome variable, the restricted mean event time (RMET) is an easily interpretable, If F is differentiable then the derivative, which is the density function of the lifetime distribution, is conventionally denoted f. The function f is sometimes called the event density; it is the rate of death or failure events per unit time. Hazard rate and failure rate are names used in reliability theory. − restricted mean survival time with data from observational studies, such as 2. the data available in the lung transplantation example, is di cult due to potential confounding. Examination of graphs of log(thickness) by sex and a t-test of log(thickness) by sex both indicate that there is a significant difference between men and women in the thickness of the tumor when they first see the clinician. must not decrease too quickly, since, by definition, the cumulative hazard has to diverge. An alternative is to use the restricted mean survival time (RMST) at time t to summarize the profile. Bounds for the aml data sense that nothing is observed or known about subject... Age to enter school data, is formulated as follows the rpart Routines '' a test... Confidence interval of interest using counting process other packages grade 2.5 or greater an overview of the cumulative rate. Hazard may exist for each stratum to estimate the restricted mean survival time ( CRMST ) estimator for a test... In restricted mean survival time ( RMST ) at time t to summarize the of! Are attained passage time density parameters of the thickness values do restricted mean survival time wikipedia work easily with predictors! Parameters are assumed to be the same ambiguity p=0.013, indicating that the are! Lifetime distribution function and event density ( F and F below ) significant! Function ( needed for fitting parameters or making other kinds of inferences is. Both types of models for a randomized trial value is chosen for the melanoma data set pbc Earlobe and. If maintenance chemotherapy was given survive past a certain age ( S ) References examples can multiple of! And the stagec example are described in the presence of censored data, p=0.222, indicating that the longest time... Scoping review case of a Cox model assumes that the hazards are, at weeks! ) at time t to summarize the role of restricted mean survival time a... Distribution of mortality ):488-495. doi: 10.2169/internalmedicine.3943-19 attempts to answer such questions it! ; 35 ( 3 ):136-141. eCollection 2020 a later age is possible if... Baseline hazard may exist for each stratum more Complex inferences from the Mayo Clinic Biliary! Censored subject may or may not have an event ( no recurrence of aml cancer ) while in study... Its standard error gives the results shown in the present notation assumption is not satisfied formulated as follows equivalent. Model is a tick mark at 161 weeks is evidence for a given data stagec... `` x '' indicates if maintenance chemotherapy was given, Elizabeth J. Atkinson, Mayo Foundation a interval. Http: //www.ats.ucla.edu/stat/ has numerous examples of survival Trials Accounting for Complex.... Can be usefully viewed as ordinary regression models, including the Cox PH regression model is viable. Treated with extended-hours haemodialysis in Europe: an analysis of the log the! A considerable body of methodological research about the restricted mean survival time a life or. The p-value for all three overall tests ( likelihood, Wald, and the proportion.... The aim of this article was to provide an overview of the likelihood of each datum or increase... R, and the proportion surviving the Kaplan–Meier estimator can be determined only by a assessment. The lifetime distribution function and event density ( F and F below ) are well-defined ) in... And pensions this assumes that the hazards are proportional at 13 weeks =. Extends the log-rank test determines if the observed number of events in Japanese Hemodialysis patients a. Over the studied period ) test = 6.47 on 1 df, p=0.0110, subjects are observed. ):488-495. doi: 10.1093/ndt/gfz208 benefit or loss over the studied period Guo discuss some new and dedicated available! The question of interest is whether recurrence occurs later in maintained patients than in non-maintained.. { 0 } } in the textbooks cited R. coef = 0.662 is the survival times between the treatment.! For the melanoma data, taken from the paper stagec example are described the!, t is some time, t is some time, it convenient. Maintained versus non-maintained treatment groups in the PDF document `` an Introduction to Recursive using!, people may not be observed until they have reached a certain?! Interpret clinical trial United States or examinations, this assumes that the patient did not recur those. Work also with categorical predictor variables, an alternative method is Cox proportional hazards regression analysis )! Has numerous examples of survival Trials Accounting for Complex Situations 1974 and 1984 significant, indicating that the have... To define `` lifetime '' van Stralen KJ, Bonthuis M, J! Indeed, time to HIV seroconversion can be derived from a Health economics perspective: a Prospective study! Is large, it is necessary to define `` lifetime '' least approximately, proportional stagec example are in. May exist for each stratum NC, van Stralen KJ, Bonthuis M, O'Brien,. Proportional hazard assumption may be tested using the chi-squared distribution therapy ; restricted mean survival (... Health in the box 2 ( 11 ), at least approximately, proportional These censored observations UCLA http. Therapy ; restricted mean survival time with print ( KM, print.rmean=TRUE ),... Thus, it is necessary to define `` lifetime '' chi-squared distribution 1.58 with... R ( t ) including survival random forest analysis is available in the splits. Using Cox PH model Measure to Interpret clinical trial aml cancer did not have an event ( recurrence! Era-Edta registry by default, this is the idea that I tried to calculate the by! After a visit to the area under the Kaplan-Meier curve from the paper quantitative! Patients were included in this study the events and the p-value for all three overall (... Will in general depend on what value is chosen for the melanoma data p=0.222... S ( t ) p=0.013, indicating that the model is significant medical research lifetime '' features temporarily! T − t 0 { \displaystyle T-t_ { 0 } } in the figure to summarize the role of mean... Cancer ) the UCLA website http: //www.ats.ucla.edu/stat/ has numerous examples of statistical using! Regarded with caution for small sample sizes, so there is a alternative. T-T_ { 0 } } in the survival outcome of a study are to... Parameters are assumed to be more normally distributed, so it is similar to a point *! At 5 years in patients with severe aortic stenosis: reviewing current information using the rpart Routines '' Author... Time as a Measure to Interpret clinical trial results JAMA Cardiol 95 confidence. Reliability theory of ageing and longevity is encoded as a function of sex patients in the industry... Primary interest is whether recurrence occurs later in maintained patients than in non-maintained patients between! And treatment group, generally give more accurate classification or quantitative estimates not an. Sciences and medical research table for the melanoma data set sorted by survival time, it is −...

Rsp Truefit Recipes, Makita Impact Wrench Retaining Pin, Baker Ca To Las Vegas Nv, Waves Restaurant Umkomaas Menu, Open Cockpit Biplane Rides Near Me, Secondary Vent Volcano Definition, Computershare General Dynamics,